What most nonprofit websites get wrong (and how to fix it)
Less thinking, more clicking.
Nonprofit websites have a tough job.
They’re expected to drive donations, promote programs, tell a compelling story, support communities — and sometimes act as a hub for events, services, or resources. All while speaking to multiple audiences at once – donors, volunteers, service seekers, and community partners.
That’s a lot to ask of one website.
Not because the mission isn’t strong, or the effort isn’t there, but because everything is trying to happen at once.
And when everything is important, nothing stands out.
The real challenge: Too many audiences, not enough direction
Most nonprofits serve multiple audiences — and that’s a good thing. It’s a sign of real impact.
But when every audience is treated as equally urgent on the website, the experience starts to break down.
A first-time visitor lands on the homepage and is immediately hit with:
multiple calls-to-action
competing messages
navigation that reflects internal structure instead of real-world intent
Instead of feeling guided, they feel like they have to figure it out themselves.
We see this all the time — especially with organizations balancing fundraising, programs, events, and community outreach. Each piece matters. But when everything is presented at once, users hesitate instead of act.
What most nonprofit websites get wrong
1. Trying to say everything at once
Mission. Impact. Programs. Events. Ways to give.
It all ends up stacked on top of each other, fighting for attention.
I get the instinct — you want people to see the full picture. But in reality, it usually just creates overload.
2. No clear primary action
When someone lands on your site, what should they do? Donate? Volunteer? Learn more? Apply for services?
If that answer isn’t obvious within a few seconds, most users aren’t going to stick around long enough to figure it out.
A strong website doesn’t just inform, it directs – with strong user pathways that lead with intent.
3. Navigation built for the organization, not the user
This is a big one.
Menus often reflect how the organization is structured:
“Programs”
“Services”
“Initiatives”
But that’s not how users think. They think in outcomes:
“I want to donate”
“I want to get involved”
“I need help”
“I want to learn more”
If your navigation doesn’t match that mindset, you’re creating friction before users even get started.
4. Too many competing CTAs
Every section has a button. Every button asks for something different.
This can lead to decision fatigue before any actual clicks occur.
We’ve seen pages where there are five different “next steps” competing for attention. And when that happens, users usually choose… none of them.
5. Over-explaining instead of guiding
Nonprofits have powerful stories to tell, but more content doesn’t always mean more clarity. Most users aren’t reading every word. They’re scanning.
So if your content isn’t structured clearly with hierarchy, spacing, and direction, even great messaging can get lost.
What to do instead
The goal isn’t to simplify your mission. It’s to simplify how people experience it. Here’s what we’ve seen work:
Define your core user journeys
Start with this question: Why are people actually coming to your site?
For most nonprofits, it comes down to a few key actions:
Donate
Get involved (volunteer, attend, support)
Access programs or services
Everything else should support these journeys — not compete with them.
Create clear, separate pathways
Not every user needs the same experience.
Instead of blending audiences together, give them clear entry points. When users can immediately see where they belong, they’re way more likely to take action (and way less likely to bounce).
This can be as simple as:
distinct homepage pathways
clearer navigation labels
landing pages tailored to specific audiences or campaigns
Prioritize clarity over completeness
You don’t need to say everything at once.
Your homepage isn’t your annual report — it’s a starting point. I always think about it as: what does someone need to understand in the first 5–10 seconds to feel confident taking the next step? Focus on that first. Then guide them deeper. Someone who has come to receive service can access that quickly. Someone who wants to dive deeper into the data will make their way to the annual report.
Design for decision-making, not just information
This is where strong websites stand out. The best nonprofit websites don’t just share information, they make it easy to decide what to do next.
Every page should quickly answer:
What is this?
Why does it matter?
What should I do next?
If users don’t have to think, they’re much more likely to act.
A better way to think about nonprofit websites
The most effective nonprofit websites aren’t digital brochures. They’re decision-making tools.
They:
attract users with clear, focused messaging
guide them through intentional pathways
remove friction from taking action
When those pieces are aligned, everything else — engagement, conversions, and ultimately impact — gets stronger.
Quick wins to improve your website today
If you’re not sure where to start, here are a few quick gut-checks I always come back to:
Can a first-time visitor understand what you do within 5 seconds?
Are your top 2-3 actions clearly prioritized on your homepage?
Does your navigation reflect user intent or internal structure?
Are you limiting primary CTAs instead of overwhelming users?
Is your content structured for scanning (not just reading)?
Are your campaigns supported by dedicated landing pages?
You don’t need a full redesign to improve performance. Sometimes, improving clarity makes the biggest difference.
Clarity > content
Nonprofit websites don’t need more content. They need more clarity.
When you make it easier for people to understand what you do, and what they should do next, you make it easier for them to engage, take action, and support your mission.
And that’s how a digital experience leads to real impact.
Frequently asked questions
What do most nonprofit websites get wrong?
They try to say everything at once. Multiple audiences — donors, volunteers, service seekers, partners — all get equally urgent treatment, which produces competing messages, navigation built around internal structure instead of user intent, and too many calls-to-action. When everything is important, nothing stands out, and users hesitate instead of act.
How many calls-to-action should a nonprofit homepage have?
Two or three, clearly prioritized. We’ve seen pages with five different “next steps” competing for attention, and when that happens users usually choose none of them. Define your core journeys — donate, get involved, access services — and let everything else support those instead of competing with them.
How do you organize navigation for a nonprofit with many programs?
Label it by what users want to do, not how the organization is structured. People think in outcomes — “I want to donate,” “I need help,” “I want to get involved” — not in internal categories like “Programs,” “Services,” and “Initiatives.” Navigation that matches that mindset removes friction before users even start.
How long should a nonprofit homepage take to understand?
Five to ten seconds. A first-time visitor should be able to answer “What is this, why does it matter, and what should I do next?” in that window. The homepage isn’t your annual report — it’s a starting point that guides people deeper.
Does a nonprofit website need a full redesign to improve?
Not always. Sometimes improving clarity makes the biggest difference: gut-check whether a first-time visitor understands what you do within five seconds, whether your top actions are prioritized, whether navigation reflects user intent, and whether your content is structured for scanning rather than reading.
Should a nonprofit website serve donors and service seekers the same way?
No. Give each audience a clear entry point — distinct homepage pathways, clearer navigation labels, landing pages tailored to specific audiences or campaigns. When users can immediately see where they belong, they’re far more likely to take action and far less likely to bounce.
About Kelly Kollmeier
Reorganize, reboot, repeat. I got viral views for Tetrising my living room furniture to perfection, but watch out – my next move is gonna be configuring eighteen different schedules so that our project is delivered on time, on budget, and with pizazz. I can’t come to your house and reorganize your life, but I can make sure your new site is received with thunderous (digital) applause.
Stay in the know
Sign up for our email newsletter. Nothing spammy about it — just a monthly rundown of what we're sharing.